The Yoga Police Are Coming

warped-ya200.jpg
 

The charismatic CEO of the Yoga Alliance, David Lipsius, hired to overhaul the failed industry standards for yoga teacher training just over a year ago, has departed his position right at the very moment his master plan is set to be implemented. Lipsius’ unexpected farewell aside, the proverbial writing has surreptitiously appeared on the wall: The organization is planning to assert new power, but whose interests are being served is not clear.

The new administration, under Lipsius, spent the last year launching a “standards review project.” This involved paying prominent industry voices for advisory opinions, facilitating working group discussions via video calls, a survey of the membership, a “listening tour” across the country, and making what appeared to be a genuine effort to receive input from the yoga community at large. Of course, this also amounted to a well-crafted public relations campaign utilizing cherry-picked statistics and the images and reputations of contributors to communicate a tacit endorsement for something that has yet to be determined by no one knows who.

Just in case you didn’t know, the Yoga Alliance is actually two separate entities…. yada yada yada.

If there is one thing that the YA wants to make abundantly clear it’s that the YA has undergone a legal restructuring. This was initially presented as a clarification of what the organization does with all the money they collect from grassroots teachers and centers often struggling to make ends meet. Since its inception, the YA has always been just a registry. It began before the internet, and having a list of teachers was thought to be a useful service to the public. But, as yoga became more popular, the registry became a major financial boon and the organization grew, amassing a greater and greater surplus of funds in its coffers. When teachers and centers started to revolt and complain that the organization doesn’t actually do anything for registrants with all the money they collect, a separate entity was created to placate the unrest.

The membership side of YA has sought to provide continuing education along with “member perks.” Unfortunately, the content produced rarely offers much outside of what can already be easily accessed on Youtube. And, frankly, the longstanding practice of taking advertising dollars in exchange for a promo code in the YA newsletter, and calling it a “member perk,” verges on fraud. The YA efforts to help prevent government regulation have been the only saving grace of the organization up until now, but the good will around this has always been contingent on the repeated assertion that the YA was never going to become the yoga police.

Did anyone even notice that the Yoga Alliance released a plan to do away with the registry and turn the membership association into a regulatory body?

In all the discussions and debates regarding the YA over the last five years of attempted reform, the point has forever been made that the registry was part of the Yoga Alliance Foundation and was for the public good, separate from the Yoga Alliance membership association. This was always important because the registry represented the “standards” that supposedly were being set as a way to protect the public from all the bad apples. But, just before Lipsius’ last day on the job, in the equivalent of a Friday-night news dump, the YA quietly released two interviews with newly hired vice presidents for the standards and credentialing committees in which it is explicitly stated that the membership association will soon be assuming a new role.

In these interviews, the decision to give the YA more power to regulate yoga is expressed as a foregone conclusion. The case being made is that “students are coming expecting a certain deliverable” and that these changes are “matching what the public is asking for.” But the membership was never asked to vote on whether or not they think the organization should do this. And the infamous survey, that will surely be pointed to, in no way establishes the will of the membership. The bias of those who think that attempting to regulate the yoga industry by establishing an arbitrary set of unenforceable hours always seems to win the day over the nuanced consideration of safe and effective yoga transmission.

Wasn’t the membership association created to serve the members, not regulate them? And why is the membership funding a foundation that it has no say in?

The YA has always basically operated as a black box in which decisions are handed down arbitrarily without transparency. For the last few years, an effort has been made to make a show that this was changing but, ultimately, there is nothing collective about how the organization is structured and the process by which determinations are made is anything but democratic. The move to transition the membership association into a regulatory body is not about helping the members in their work of teaching yoga, or even making yoga teachers more qualified. The course being charted is really about meeting customer expectations and serving market forces that demand never-ending growth.

Also, funding teachers and organizations that bring yoga to underserved and marginalized communities is a wonderful thing, but when the money is extracted from yoga teachers under false pretenses and directed by the prerogatives of the administration instead of the membership, the organization is no longer operating as representative of teachers and centers but dictating its own agenda. More importantly, we have no reason to believe that the YA is prepared to act as the regulator of yoga in a responsible way. It has never shown itself in the past to be up for such an impossible task, and the departure of the visionary who was supposed to lead us into the promised land does not bode well.

No great progress has ever been made by replicating the mistakes of the past. If the YA wants to serve yoga, rather than the assorted political and economic interests of only a few, then it needs to break free of the prison it has built for itself.

The perennial arguments that if we don’t regulate ourselves then the government will, or that yoga injuries are on the rise and we have to protect the public, really don’t hold up under scrutiny. In states that have worked with local governments to regulate yoga teacher training by treating them like vocational schools, the protections that are being created do not address the substantive issues of yoga curriculum that the YA “standards” have perpetuated. Creating a code of ethics and a scope of practice, and devising a process for redress, can be done regardless of how many hours a yoga teacher-training course may be.

The conflation of hours with standards has profoundly undermined the competency of yoga teachers. Until we are honest with ourselves about this fundamental flaw then we will continue to bleed the profession of its spirit and betray our ideals. Only if we have the courage to smash the black box and have a real reform of the organization might we discover new ways of providing guidelines and resources that lift teachers up to a higher standard of personal conduct, and hold them to account for what they say they do. That YA is looking to increase hours and become the yoga police is the making of an even greater disaster. If those with vested interest in the yoga profession don’t want to see a continuation of all that has gone wrong, then now is the time to step up and put a stop to it.

22 Comments

J. Brown

J. Brown is a yoga teacher, writer, and founder of Abhyasa Yoga Center in Brooklyn, New York. A teacher for 15 years, he is known for his pragmatic approach to teaching personal, breath-centered therapeutic yoga that adapt to individual needs. His writing has been featured in Yoga Therapy Today, the International Journal of Yoga Therapy, Elephant Journal and Yogadork.

Fear and Purpose Amidst a Narrative Collapse

Fear and Purpose Amidst a Narrative Collapse

I’ve had a particularly hard time bringing myself to write. That’s unusual. Two other articles on various topics have already been penned but both feel so entirely inadequate to the moment that I can’t bring myself to publish either. Looking for insights into humanity through an examination of what is happening in the yoga industry has its limitations, and my usual sort of musings seem a trifling contribution given the larger shifts taking place.

Read More

Are We Entering a Yoga Desert?

Are We Entering a Yoga Desert?

Having grown up in the eighties, I have no memories of fresh produce at our dinner table, much less anything organic. Often, my whole family sat around watching tv with individual fold-out trays in front of us, eating Chun King frozen Chinese hors d’oeuvres that were heated in a microwave oven and served in the plastic container we bought them in. Back then, convenience and economy were valued over nutrition….

Read More

Yoga Teacher, Heal Thyself

Yoga Teacher, Heal Thyself

There is a performative aspect to teaching and promoting group yoga classes that sometimes leads to a denial of the teacher’s actual state. The conventional dynamics at play between teachers and students, both interpersonal and economic, are presenting obstacles to the kinds of exchange that encourage effective yoga transmission. Maintaining integrity often means having the courage to buck trends.

Read More

Shell Games Keep the Myth Alive

Shell Games Keep the Myth Alive

Nothing exemplifies the false narratives perpetuated by the yoga industrial complex more than a recent Yoga Journal headline that read: “How to Make $5 Classes Sustainable.” These stories, often well-intentioned, are the product of outdated modes of thinking that turn earnest people into unwitting hypocrites. Challenging the status quo by returning to an earlier stage in the evolution of yoga transmission might be the best way forward.

Read More

Proper Alignment in Yoga

Proper Alignment in Yoga

Generally speaking, when someone sets out to learn a new skill there is a natural human impulse to want to get it right. Being able to do a yoga pose in a certain way often becomes an extrapolated question of safety. Doing it right means safety. Doing it wrong means injury. Unfortunately, anyone who has engaged in a deep inquiry of yoga knows that looking for rights and wrongs to follow when it comes to practice is not a unhelpful context.

Read More

Less Pandering, Less Students

Less Pandering, Less Students

There is a convenient irony to the way the yoga-related industry effectively exploits the weaknesses in people that yoga purports to address. As teachers come clean with themselves on what they are actually doing, and make choices truer to their evolving understanding of yoga, they often find their class sizes begin to wane. Fostering the beneficial purpose of yoga teachings in our society will require us to better navigate trade-offs...

Read More

The Unexplainable Importance of Yoga

The Unexplainable Importance of Yoga

We’ve all heard about the amazing things that yoga can do for us, but try explaining exactly what it is and how it works and you quickly find yourself on shaky ground. There is an innate something at the heart of the matter that simply cannot be measured, only felt. As unsatisfying as this may be, the highly subjective perception of our own experience is the only real basis for any understanding, and the very thing that makes yoga so vital.

Read More

A Case for Anarchy in Yoga

A Case for Anarchy in Yoga

Radical transformation is the provenance of yoga. The promise of bringing about change in oneself through will and determination, being able to derive truth and purpose by observing our own experience rather than succumbing to societal conditioning or the influence of outside authorities, is inherently revolutionary. Truly authentic expressions always seem to retain a spark of the unknown that refuses to be ordered.

Read More

Lineage or Family Business?

Lineage or Family Business?

A lot of people in the yoga world are feeling confused. Changing social tides and startling revelations are calling into question the foundations on which many a career have been built. Deep vacuums have been created with the passing of primary teachers, previously held secrets are being exposed, and the emergence of a neo-orthodoxy is attempting to lay claim to what was once considered an open-source transmission.

Read More

The Future of Yoga is Small

The Future of Yoga is Small

The algorithms and operating systems that are governing our experiences, intended to expand our reach and connect us to the broader world, have borne unforeseen and adverse repercussions. This is particularly true for yoga teachers and center owners looking to cohere the intimacy and connection they feel through yoga with the realities of the profession. Only If we can abandon flawed models might such a balance be struck.

Read More

Yoga's Greatest Challenge

Yoga's Greatest Challenge

A lot of people who go to yoga classes are not really interested in yoga. At least, not in the sense of being seriously committed and willing to take on a radical inquiry into the nature of being, and having the courage to manifest what is discovered in attitudes and actions. The trappings of mainstream yoga have led to an obfuscation of not only the greater challenge for individuals but the potential rewards for our communities at large.

Read More